Sheri was very close to five stars with this book. It was only let
down by a few elements that were overly contrived and unrealistic, yet
were essential to make the main point of the story. Unfortunately I
can’t go into detail about these without giving away a lot of the plot.
This is something I strive to avoid in my reviews. So I will confine
myself to saying that these contrived aspects of the story don’t
detract in any meaningful way from the excellence of this book.
So what is ‘Gibbon’s Decline and Fall’ about? Yes that’s right it’s
millennium fever time. It’s the year 2000 and life as we know it is
on it’s last legs. This doesn’t sound like a ringing endorsement does
it? This is what happens when you some up an enormously complex novel
in one sentence.
The book open with a prologue in 1959 with Carolyn, the main character,
just enrolling at University. In the next few pages Sheri manages to
set up the rest of the main characters, but without seeming to dump
vast quantities of information on you. It is a skill many authors
could learn from.
The title has a double role in this book. It captures the central
theme, ie the decline and fall of modern society. It is also the
basis of the friendship the main characters form. The start the
‘Decline and Fall Club’ to help one of their friends. This Club then
becomes a central part of their lives. They vow to met every year
from its inception. This vow is upheld as we jump from the prologue
into the main story in the year 2000 where Carolyn is organising the
next meeting at her place.
Diverse things are happening around the world leading to much unpleasantness.
The book gets steadily more and more horrific until somewhere near the
middle when Sheri starts to explain why things are going like they are.
This released a lot of the tension for me. Once I knew why things
where happening, I could envisage solutions.
It is at this point that Sheri begins to bring the members of the DFC
(Decline and Fall Club) back together. All of their skills and
experience over the last 40 years hilighting different aspects of the
problem. This is one of the contrived elements I mentioned. The DFC
is a small group of people, yet they represent every aspect of the
human condition, whether it be social status, sexuality, spirituality. I was unconvinced of the likelihood of such diverse range of people occurring in such a small group, but it works for this story. It is necessary to make the point, I feel, Sheri is aiming for.
I can’t go into much more detail about the plot now without giving
away the story, but I will make an obscure reference to the end. It
won’t spoil the story as you probably won’t know what I’m raving about
unless you’ve read the book.
My initial reaction on reaching the end of the book was, "You bitch.
You didn’t tell me." That thought was followed a heartbeat later by,
"Thank god you didn’t tell me. It would have ruined the book."
Almost everything is resolved in the conclusion. Ordinarily a major
loose end, like the on Sheri leaves unanswered, would annoy me, but
the nature of this book and the nature of what is left unresolved,
couldn’t have been finished any other way. Any answer that Sheri could
give to the final question would be loved by a large number of people
and hated by twice as many. Sheri clearly wants people to think about
the question rather then be indoctrinated with her views. For this
reason only I would highly recommend this book. It asks some very
important questions without preaching an answer.
While the book is set in the year 2000. I don’t feel it will become
dated after 2000. It is a book with a vision as profound as ‘1984’
and I sincerely hope Sheri is wrong. This is a damn good book. Read
it now or after the year 2000, but read it.